Insights / Design
What first-time managers actually need
New managers get sent to leadership training and come back with a vocabulary. What they needed was practice at three specific conversations.
By McKinley Malbrough III, J.D., MS-HRM. Published September 7, 2026.
What are the three conversations?
Corrective feedback to somebody who was a peer last month. Receiving a complaint about a colleague. Telling somebody no about money, title or time off.
Every new manager will face all three within a year, and almost none of them will have practiced any of them out loud before the real one.
Why does leadership theory fail here?
Because it gives language for the situation without giving the words for the moment. A manager who can define psychological safety still freezes when an employee starts crying.
Practice beats framework. Run the conversation, get it wrong in a room where it is safe to, get specific feedback, run it again.
What is the biggest legal exposure with new managers?
The complaint they do not pass on. Once a supervisor knows, the employer knows, and an untrained manager who decides to handle it quietly has started an obligation nobody else is aware of.
Train that before you train anything else. It is a 30 minute module that prevents the most expensive category of mistake.
How often should this be refreshed?
Once at promotion, then a short session at six months when they have real situations to bring. The second one is far more useful than the first and almost nobody runs it.
Keep going
Programs
Four live programs, capped at twelve people.
The playbook
My one page session plan, free.
Store
Programs, courses and merchandise.
Want this applied to your own session?
Book twenty minutes and bring the agenda you are stuck on.